Logo

Student Corner

Is Black Hole a Wormhole?

Written by: Sohan Bhattarai - 25003, Grade XII

Posted on: 10 September, 2024

Introduction

Many researchers pay attention to black holes and wormholes that appear camouflaged among constellations. Black holes are considered space objects that behave like gigantic magnets that attract even light in space. They are thought to form from the collapse of massive stars. Wormholes, on the other hand, are hypothetical tunnels in spacetime that could allow travel across vast distances, possibly exceeding the speed of light. From a scientific point of view, such curiosity is born out of the possible relationship between these two cosmic objects. They argue that, at least in some sense, it is possible that one or two black holes could be turned into this kind of entity, although it is also possible that it may have been related to something similar. This thought excites scientists as it seems to be promising to unveil other angles to explore the universe and even space travel, something we saw only in movies and in our dreams before.

 

BlackHoles: A Mysterious Object

Black holes are the most unknown objects in the visible Universe, or the objects which are the focus of the present astrophysical research. The nomenclature of black holes is given from the fact that black holes are so massive that nothing in them, including light, can ever come out of them. This involves anything that from time to time was near a short-lived but enormously large star at the time it turned into a black hole. A black hole is derived from the exercise of gravitational force which results in the massive stars’ collapse in such a way that incredible compression in the star’s centre, profound gravity, draws the outer portion of the star and causes a black hole to be formed. The singularity of a black hole is the infinitely dense point situated at the centre of the collapsed star. Born from supermassive stars that are numerous times larger than the sun, the singularity is always surrounded by what is referred to as the event horizon, the point beyond which nothing can get out. Black holes are categorised with the mass they possess and depending on this mass, they are referred to as stellar black holes or supermassive black holes. That is what forms the event horizon and singularity, which is the stuff that makes a black hole so intriguing.

 

Wormholes

Astronomers studying thick interstellar space aim to detect evidence of wormholes, a theoretical concept in physics. Wormholes are theoretical bridges in spacetime with the conjectured ability to transport matter through larger distances and possibly faster than light. In General Relativity, it was postulated that gravity curves space-time and, when these equations are applied to absurdly large objects like black holes or other astronomically larger objects, the equations yield the theoretical hypothetical entities called Schwarzschild wormholes. This is where the most accurately calculated mathematical models of wormholes stem from — solutions to Einstein’s field equations. These are wormholes which are possibly navigable; they do not have the gravitational collapse that is characteristic of Schwarzschild wormholes. This type is named after two astrophysics professors at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology who predicted their existence in 1988. Morris-Thorne wormholes are therefore solutions to the vacuum Einstein equations, implying that there is no necessary extra energy. These exist as a class of numerical solutions to the Einstein field equations, but whether such a shortcut could be as stable as to be used is still uncertain. Another layer of complexity is added to the quest for a perfect theory of wormholes, jittery spacetime can be stretched to form multi-page books, while immense black holes, which devour galaxies, leave cosmic ashes, and form gravity fields which can send photons very far.

 

Differences between Black Holes and Wormholes

The distinction between black holes and traversable wormholes is the differences in their properties with regard to gravity and also their other weak properties. Black holes are obtained through the gravitational compaction of a massive star and involve an inescapable force of gravity driving towards an event horizon where the pressure beyond which cannot be escaped. For a black hole, the singularity is a point of infinite density, while spacetime theory allows a class of stabilized shortcuts called traversable wormholes only in spacetime in case there is exotic matter with negative energy densities. In theory, these ‘hypothetical passages’ would not accompany the gravitational collapse with which the formation of a black hole is usually accompanied, and, can be pathways that enable one to travel from one part of the universe to another. Observable phenomenology also differs; black holes distort near their mouths as bending of nearby light paths and gravitational lensing but similar to traversable wormholes we can only infer its existence. Such an understanding helps to define connections between gravity and space-time that in turn give an insight into these mysterious phenomena occurring in space.

 

Challenges and Controversies

There are theoretical difficulties when theoretical physicists attempt to synchronize the basic regulating laws for such cosmic events. While black holes have been described as objects with measurable effects including the bending of light as described by Einstein’s theory of general relativity, how the same could be transformed into a traversable wormhole has been a compounding mystery. Further scientific questions relating to the existence and the stabilization of traversable wormholes are some of the most philosophical due to the hypothetical use of exotic matter with negative energy density which defies conventional physics. 

 

There are also some problems in the process of associating theory with empirical evidence. Observation of black holes using the characteristic property that they swallow light is impossible in the usual sense. Empirical validations also do not exist for traversable wormholes themselves, which are theoretical constructs and hence a major source of confusion regarding their existence. The current tools of observation and other technologies are not sufficient to inspect these cosmic phenomena; they need new methods to decipher and explain the mysteries and theoretical difficulties at the juncture of black holes and traversable wormholes.

 

Current Research and Observational Efforts

Scientists investigate black holes and wormholes in order to acquire information on these subjects, which is actually quite fascinating and unique in the context of the universe. Hence, they employ sophisticated instruments and gadgets to assist in observations. Future studies will explore just what it is that these enigmatic objects do and how the impact of them may be observed in the universe. Some of the newest scientists would like to know where they are and what they want, black holes and wormholes. However, using the present day’s technology to conduct cosmological experiments and attempt to study such quantum black holes and wormholes in the actual galaxy is still fiction. Thus, the only possibility for their reproduction at the present moment is to replace them with the help of some other tabletop experiments, for instance, a small-scale quantum computer, etc. They plan to peer deep into the cosmos and investigate and discover the very nature of such strange entities and how they impact the fundamental structure of the universe and time. These (efforts) as you may know are intended to discover more about the universe and they may one day lead to great discoveries that will in one way or another bring about significant changes in our understanding of the universe.

 

Practical Applications:

Furthermore, theoretical scientists are not only thinking of this as a way of gaining knowledge but they also have thoughts of thinking of how to come up with handy uses of such knowledge. Of all these possibilities, there is one that has shocked experimenters and theorists through one channel or another – the theoretical consideration of traversable wormholes. Thus, in theory, tunnels of this sort may be cosmic shortcuts enabling faster-than-light travel and building bigger channels that permit interstellar communication. The future of space exploration holds exciting possibilities for how these spacetime corridors might work in practice. However, turning these ideas into reality requires both ethical considerations and technological understanding. The appearance of ethical questions is quite logical, scientifically-restrained possibilities and their negative potential in the context of spacetime distortion must be balanced by the scientists. Furthermore, the technicality of creating stable and traversable wormholes is a technical maze that science has to navigate. Moving to the wider but sometimes plausible area of evidenced or at least hypothesized real-world applicability, ever-rising imagination is enhancing the concept of space travel and communication across stars with traversable wormholes.

 

Conclusion

Wormholes are thought to be black holes that act as bridges in space-time, which is an interesting but unproven idea in physics. Theoretically, black holes and wormholes are both related since they come from Einstein’s equations of general relativity. A black hole can have a singularity at its centre with only a way event horizon while a wormhole is expected to be some kind of tunnel connecting far-away regions of space-time. Scientists currently believe that black holes are not wormholes because there has been no observational evidence to support this possibility and significant problems exist in the theory models that describe them.
References:

  • https://www.britannica.com/science/wormhole
  • https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0577907320301374
  • https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/283627/whats-the-difference-between-wormholes-and-black-holes
  • https://www.space.com/build-wormhole-using-extra-tiny-dimensions
  • https://www.quora.com/What-are-some-challenges-faced-while-studying-black-holes
  • https://www.msstate.edu/newsroom/article/2023/01/study-possible-wormholes-space-lands-msus-ye-prestigious-scientific#:~:text=%E2%80%9CThe%20cosmological%20experiments%20to%20study,real%20option%20at%20this%20moment.
  • https://link.springer.com/article/10.1140/epjc/s10052-023-11456-4